On September 14, 2018, James Allen made the discovery and notified first responders by phone. In the basement of a house in Tecumsea, Michigan, a former resident claimed to have found his wife, Amy Allen, hanging from the ceiling.
An autopsy report revealed that Amy died as a result of her husband James Allen’s attempt to suffocate her, although what initially appeared to be a suicide was later confirmed to be a murder.
Amy was believed to have died when paramedics arrived at the scene until a faint pulse was found. She was rushed to a nearby hospital, but to no avail. Reportedly, she died there from injuries. James Allan was charged with murder after being implicated in various testimonies, autopsy records, and evidence at the crime scene. The jury was later found guilty of second-degree murder.
Amy Allan’s case is the latest in the new Dateline series The Last Day. Now available for exclusive Peacock streaming covering the murder investigation.
— Peacock (@peacockTV) June 16, 2022
Where is Amy Allan’s spouse, James Allan, now?
When James Allen appeared in court, he pleaded not guilty to all charges. He maintained his innocence in the murder of his wife, Amy Allen. The prosecution’s case follows the defendant strangling and killing her Amy with her bare hands in a conference room. He plotted an elaborate suicide plan to deceive the police. But he eventually became entangled in his own false net.
After hearing various eyewitness accounts and conducting an autopsy, the jury ultimately concluded that James was charged with second-degree murder. He was sentenced to 45 years in prison in 2021, almost three years later. To qualify for parole, he had to serve at least 20 years. So James could be released early in 2040 while incarcerated at St. Louis Penitentiary in St. Louis, Michigan.
Why was James Allen convicted of the murder of his wife, Amy Allen?
James Allen’s calm and unusual behavior, who made the panicked phone call, originally aroused suspicion when rescue teams arrived at the scene. When officials arrived at the scene, it was reported that he had already performed CPR and attempted to resuscitate Amy Allan.
The autopsy revealed that the wire around Amy’s neck was not taut enough to cause loss of consciousness. It aggravated the suspicion. When detectives began accusing her spouse, he was eventually detained in Ocala, Florida.
— Dateline NBC (@DatelineNBC) June 21, 2022
James was the first to propose the suicide scenario, and he held it up throughout the trial. He also claimed that his wife had a history of alcohol abuse and often caused bipolar behavior. Their seemingly perfect marriage turned out to be less than ideal as more investigations and trials came to light. In court, prosecutors claimed that James Allen choked Amy until he lost consciousness after the incident with Amy. They also claimed that James was an oppressive and violent husband.
A jury found him guilty of second degree murder in the murder of his wife, James Allen. After a two-week trial that included numerous testimonies from trial participants who participated, either directly or indirectly. The defendant pleaded not guilty to the end. However, he was sentenced to more than 40 years in prison and is likely to be released on parole later.
Last Day, a Dateline series currently available to stream on Peacock, tells the heartbreaking story of the tragic murder of Amy Allan.